Best Mattress Under 500 – Reviews And Buying Guide 2018

SandraMcelroyBy SandraMcelroySep 16, 20170

Now, as I am writing this review, a cliché keeps resonating in my mind – you get what you pay for, right?

Well, wrong!

At least, not when you are shopping for the best mattress under 500 in my view. Traditional mattresses as we know them are changing. Increasingly, technological advancements and innovations contend for cheaper mattress productions.

Does the quality suffer? Not at all.

In fact, I was in awe about how some of the best mattresses under $500 performed as I subjected them through the rigors of testing. As you might know, cutthroat competition in the mattress industry is playing right into consumers’ hands. I dare say this is the best time to grab a mattress for you. But before you do, let me share with you some of my favorite picks from this category.

Our Best 5 Picks

  • Tuft & Needle Mattress, Full Mattress with T&N Adaptive Foam
  • Editor’s Pick - The Best Product
  • Our Rating: (5 / 5)
  • Perfect Cloud UltraPlush Gel-Max 10 Inch Memory Foam Mattress
  • Runner Up/Alternative Pick - The Second Best Product
  • Our Rating: (4.7 / 5)
  • Best Price Mattress 8-Inch Memory Foam Mattress, Twin
  • Budget Pick - The Best Product with Limited Budget
  • Our Rating: (4.5 / 5)
  • Zinus 12 Inch Gel-Infused Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress, Queen
  • Upgrade Pick - The Highest Quality Product with High Price
  • Our Rating: (4.7 / 5)
  • Live and Sleep Resort Classic Full / Double Size 10 Inch Cooling Medium
  • Niche Pick - The Best Mattress Under 1000
  • Our Rating: (4.7 / 5)

**Below, you’ll see more detailed reviews, but you can also click the links above to see current prices and read customer’s reviews on Amazon.

  5 Best Mattress Under 500 For An Affordable Sleep

Tuft & Needle Mattress, Full Mattress With T&N Adaptive Foam

Tuft & Needle Mattress, Full Mattress with T&N Adaptive Foam


Features to Consider:

Tuft & Needle mattresses need no introduction. They have carved a niche for themselves for delivering the best quality. This particular model has over 10,000 reviews on Amazon, and it was an easy pick for my favorite best product. No wonder, in 2015 it scooped the award of #1 Brand Mattress by product review organization. The following year in 2016, it rated as the “Best Buy” product.

Home to a long list of champions, this mattress is a product of Tuft & Needle’s own proprietary foam. It is different from the normal memory foam. It has two layers of high density polyfoam. The first 3” inches are quality adaptive foam infused with gel to give you a cool and comfortable night. It’s almost a perfect craft, not too firm, and not too soft. Also, it has excellent motion isolation tendencies, which is a nice proposition for shifty partners. The remaining 7” inches are pure support foam, which adds to the longevity factor. Also, the top cover is a craft of rayon and polyester, which sets it as tough and stretchy.

My View:

I love this company, for one thing – transparency. Besides, you get 100 nights of the free trial and a proper 10 years warranty, notwithstanding the superior workmanship that is evident, at least according to my view. From the onset, I love the finishing and feel. At $500, I think this mattress looks cozy and luxurious. If the looks would not impress you, then how it contours around your body will. Also, the top layer of adaptive foam easily collapses on pressure points, but does not sink. This comfort, coupled with its cool nature makes for a restful night.  


  • Honest and quality workmanship

  • 10 year gimmick-less warranty and 100-day trial period

  • Motion isolation

  • Fairly affordable for its pedigree

  • Great customer support


  • Some people say it’s too firm

Perfect Cloud UltraPlush Gel-Max 10 Inch Memory Foam Mattress

Perfect Cloud UltraPlush Gel-Max 10 Inch Memory Foam Mattress


Features to Consider:

Perfect Cloud Ultra Plush is a joy to watch, at least to my eye when I first laid my eyes on this mattress. Also, I have seen many mattresses include the name plush in their description, to me, this mattress embodies the true meaning of plush. I have come to appreciate the artistry of its construction.

To start us off, its cover is knitted from stretchy quality cotton-polyester embroidery, depicting smooth patterns and curves. Being able to remove the cover with ease delighted me. The cover in fact adopts the innovative Gusset Air-Transfer technology, keeping you cool through the hot summer months.The mattress has three layers, 1.5” inch layer of air infused memory foam, which gives the mattress its plush feel. The second layer is 2” inch gel-max memory foam responsible for the mattress’ coolness. To complete this workmanship is 6” inches of HD base support foam that gives the mattress its strength and longevity.

For me, products that offer 100% guarantee more than less depicts the structural integrity of that product. However, to add a 25-year warranty really covers all bases for me and from the onset, this mattress looks like it is durable. I found it soft to sleep on, perhaps a little too soft for some people. Also, it embraces pressure points like your hips and back to give you a pain-free night.

My View:

First of all, I always prefer products that instill confidence from the onset, and this mattress does just that to qualify as my second pick. I was impressed by its superior workmanship and the quality of material used in its construction. Even impressive, you may find it just the right mix of plush and firmness. To top layer with its air-infusion provides excellent breathability and heat dissipation. It has some stellar reviews from customers which point to its functionality. Furthermore, safety is paramount when considering a mattress to buy. It is CertiPUR-US certified as free from harmful chemicals and radical agents.


  • Plush sleeping environment

  • Innovative cover with latest air transfer technology

  • CertiPUR-US certified as safe

  • Gel-Max is excellent at cooling mattresses

  • Aesthetically appealing


  • Does not hold well on typical box spring bed

  • “New memory foam” odor that dissipates in 12 hours

Best Price Mattress 8-Inch Memory Foam Mattress, Twin

Best Price Mattress 8-Inch Memory Foam Mattress, Twin


Features to Consider:

Best Price mattress company has developed a knack for affordability. If you would like a basic yet quality mattress, then this mattress may fit your bill. However, it was my favorite pick for a budget product because of the value it brings to the table. To start you off it comes with a poly jacquard cover with zippers to aid in easy removal and washing.

Secondly, you get 2” inches of memory foam, 2” inches of super soft pressure-release memory foam and finally, 4” inches of high-density support base foam. All these layers converge to contend for a comfortable mattress surface. Not only does it hug comfortably to your contours but also intelligently recognizes pressure points and collapse further to distribute your weight evenly.  This memory foam has three ingredients – Green tea, Charcoal, and Natural Castor oil all for dealing with odor and bacteria, a task I feel it excels.

My View:

I have always wondered how this firm affords so much sophistication at the price level they retail their mattresses. The company took a deliberate root to revolutionize the design and manufacturing protocols of a mattress. They identified potential cost leaks and sealed them.

Therefore, consumers can get quality mattresses at very low prices, something that impressed me. To prove their quality, they got necessary certifications from the stringent tests administered by CertiPUR-US. They have also added a 10 year warranty. I found the surface of it to be quite responsive, with active suspension features. This is useful in isolating motion transfer and distributes weight evenly.


  • Unbelievably comfortable and affordable

  • Responsive active suspension to isolate motion transfer

  • Even distribution of weight

  • Active charcoals to maintain freshness and deal with odor

  • Real bamboo jacquard cover oozes with quality


  • A little firm especially if you have back pain

  • Takes a while to inflate to its factory measurements

Zinus 12 Inch Gel-Infused Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Zinus 12 Inch Gel-Infused Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress, Queen


Feature to Consider:

Zinus Mattresses have been in the industry for the last 26 years. Indeed, you would want to believe that with all this experience they have advanced their products. Well, it’s no surprise they have enhanced the quality of their products. This mattress is an innovation of green tea and gel infusion into memory foam. The result is a cool, conforming, and comfortable memory foam mattress. The green tea inclusion technology acts as a natural odor retardant. In addition, this mattress has in it castor natural seed oil to deal with bacteria and allergens.

Secondly, what impressed me was its adoption of these natural and organic extracts. Consequently, it makes for a nice mattress for the whole family in my opinion. As you may know, normal memory foam mattresses have a tendency to trap heat. Zinus have created four layers in a single mattress that assists with airflow and heat dissipation. First of all, the initial layer is 2” inches of gel memory foam. Then 3” inches of comfort foam, followed by 3.5” inches of Airflow HD foam.It then comes with 3.5” inches of airflow HD base support foam.

My View:

I picked this mattress as my favorite premium product for a few reasons. First of all, its exceptional pressure relieving comfort, minimal heat retention in all corners and beautifully crafted edge support. Also, I found the first layer creating a hugging feel; soft and cushy but firm enough to support your weight. Moreover, it handles motion isolation fairly well. The second and third layers handle their functions almost perfectly. The entire mattress is breathable and highly responsive. Furthermore, it doesn’t retain heat. The sleeping surface is consistently cool, a remarkable achievement for a memory foam based mattress.


  • Advanced heat regulation

  • Use of organic products such as green tea and caster natural oils to deal with odors

  • “New foam” smell dissipates quickly

  • Innovative packaging that is easy to carry

  • Superior edge support

  • Orthopedic support for the spine

  • Ideal firmness for side/stomach sleepers


  • It is an expensive mattress but worth every coin

  • A little too soft for some people

Live And Sleep Resort Classic Full / Double Size 10 Inch Cooling Medium-Firm Memory Foam Mattress And Pillow

Live and Sleep Resort Classic Full / Double Size 10 Inch Cooling Medium-Firm Memory Foam Mattress and Pillow


Features to Consider:

Live and Sleep is a fairly new company in the mattress industry. However, they are quickly making a name for themselves with attractive and quality mattresses. I think being a new company trying to carve a niche for themselves drives them to produce quality mattresses. The mattress I feel has quality features of a premium mattress that would cost a lot more. The first 2.5” inches consists of premium visco foam infused with airflow, and the rest is high-density support base. This visco foam feels sufficiently cool and aerated. If you have body ache issues, especially the back, this probably would be a nice pick.

I found it offers medium firmness, picking up pressure points and offering relief. You will not feel the need to keep tossing and turning trying to adjust the pain points. It gives the legendary marshmallow sensation. The cover is made of flax linen, which is a quality fabric and aesthetically appealing.  

My View:

I’m a fan of value-adds, it shows the company is serious. I don’t get to see many mattress company doing this, but Live and Sleep gives you a free visco-elastic pillow. It nicely complements their mattress. The almost perfect deluxe cushion visco foam contours nicely around your body in an ideal posture. Hence, it prevents muscle aches and joint soreness. In addition, the top layer is highly breathable and cool; you feel relaxed throughout the night. The cover made of linen offers great comfort and soothes your skin.


  • Visco-elastic foam mattress for extra comfort

  • Comes with a free visco-elastic pillow

  • Quality linen top cover

  • Extremely breathable

  • Tremendous body support to prevent aches and pains

  • 20 years warranty


  • Could do with firmer edge support

  • Some mattresses are not uniformly finished

How To Choose The Best Mattress Under 500

How to choose the best mattress under 500

Mattress companies have to shade off a few qualities to offer you a mattress under $500. Fortunately, with new technologies some companies still produce quality mattresses, you will normally find to be pricey. Some of the qualities you should check for when selecting the best mattress under $500 is its density. I’m certain you have heard of the terms soft, firm, medium firm, etc. While it is okay to feel with your hand and measure the resistance, the most scientific way is to read the indentation load deflection (ILD) tag. Generally, the higher the value of the ILD, the firmer the mattress gets.

Also, take advantage of reviews like this one and those found on Amazon. They can be reliable at painting a real picture of how a mattress handles the rigors of life. You also want to check the built material. This may not necessarily be very important in the advent of innovations in the mattress industry. Similarly, check and read the fine print and pay particular attention to guarantee tag and check out what the warranty covers.

What Are The Advantages Of Best Mattress Under 500?

What are the Advantages of Best Mattress Under 500?

Well, for me the most important benefit is savings. These mattresses are obviously affordable. The question you may want to ask – at what cost? Fortunately, these mattresses hold their own against their big brothers to offer you quality. Below are some of the benefits of the best mattresses under $500:

  • Innovation

    To be able to compete, these must adapt new innovative ideas that save on the cost of production but offer quality above traditional ones. For instance, Best Price Company went back and re-looked their production chain. No wonder, they have revolutionized the entire manufacturing line. You usually get more than what you bargained for.

  • No Frills

    In addition, simplicity is the way to survive, sometimes you just need a simple, functional mattress without all the complications of an expensive mattress. This is true especially for individuals who are sensitive to odors or are allergic to many additions highly priced mattresses come with.

  • Quality Assurance

    Even though they are relatively affordable, most of these boast of certifications. Moreover, from highly acclaimed quality assurance bodies like CertiPUR-US and GreenGuard.

Attributes That Differentiate Best Mattress Under 500

You don’t just go for any mattress, as there are basic features you have to consider. This guide alerts you on our favorite picks in each category. As you head out to shop, do consider the following attributes:

  • Innovation

  • Firmness

  • Build materials

  • Certifications

  • Durability

  • Warranty and trials

  • Customer support

What Is The Best Way To Use This Product?

As always, follow manufacturer’s instructions. Also, make sure that you get a product that has sufficient amount of warranty. Better still, try to select companies that let you try their mattresses for at least 90 days. This is a reasonable period to determine the structural integrity of a mattress.

Do Best Mattresses Under 500 Suffer From Quality Issues?

Do Best Mattresses Under 500 Suffer from Quality Issues?

I have often heard people associate price with quality. Consequently,  this school of thought seems to suggest that relatively affordable mattresses suffer quality deficiencies. Whereas this may be true with other aspects, it’s not an assumption when it comes to mattresses under $500. I have tested mattresses that would easily rival their pricey big brothers. There are many factors that contribute to this phenomenon including technological advancement to simple production and cost restructuring. All these savings are aggregated, and it’s passed onto the consumers in the form of an affordable mattress.

Read more:


In Conclusion

Above all, Tuft & Needle mattress is my favorite as the best mattress under 500. The company has been around long enough to know a lot about the production of quality mattresses. Their customer support responsiveness is excellent when you need help with a query. Apart from quality make, this mattress is aesthetically appealing. Also, it feels cozy and comfortable on your skin. All this for under $500 is a steal in my view.

Read Other Latest Test!


This is Sandra McElroy. My mission is to help BedtimeFriends readers research, & pick mattresses & various other sleep products that suit their needs, & budget.
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *