Best Baby Mattress – Reviews And Buying Guide 2018

SandraMcelroyBy SandraMcelroyNov 1, 20170
Best Baby Mattress

Did you know a wrong mattress places your baby to be susceptible to SIDs (Sudden Infant Death)? Our little angels, soft and tender demand the very best sleep surface. Besides, babies don’t have a fully developed immune system to fight off microbial elements and allergens.

Furthermore, baby cribs are literally growth and development centers. Incidentally, babies spend around up to 17 hours in a 24-hour cycle sleeping. It therefore naturally follows that you have to procure the best baby mattress. Which are these? Sit tight as I take you through my top five picks.

Our Best 5 Picks

  • Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress
  • Editor’s Pick - The Best Product
  • Our Rating: (5 / 5)
  • Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress
  • Runner Up/Alternative Pick - The Second Best Product
  • Our Rating: (4.7 / 5)
  • Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress
  • Budget Pick - The Best Product with Limited Budget
  • Our Rating: (4.5 / 5)
  • Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress
  • Upgrade Pick - The Highest Quality Product with High Price
  • Our Rating: (5 / 5)
  • Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
  • Niche Pick - The Best Mattress Under 1000
  • Our Rating: (4.7 / 5)

**Below, you’ll see more detailed reviews, but you can also click the links above to see current prices and read customer’s reviews on Amazon.

Here Are 5 Best Mattress For Babies In 2017

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress, Organic Cotton Cover

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress, Organic Cotton Cover


Features to Consider:

Does Colgate manufacture mattresses too? Well, not exactly the same franchise that manufactures toothpaste. Colgate Eco-Classica III is arguably among the best mattresses for babies. It is the top of my picks because of its distinctive features. It has an innovative dual firmness make, with one side optimized for infant firmness and as your baby transitions to a toddler, you simply flip the mattress over to the toddler firmness side. This best baby mattress is 6” inches thick, crafted orthopedically into a standard dual firmness lightweight crib foam mattress. Additionally, it is gel infused with plant oils.

Sensibly, the federal government has issued tougher policies that protect babies, and baby mattresses are no exception. It is therefore reassuring to know this mattress passes both the GREENGUARD standard and CertiPur-US tests. It has antimicrobial properties and hypoallergenic, very important for the health of your baby. Similarly, the cover is made of certified cotton, with an undercover waterproof lining and is easily washable.

My View:

What I loved most about Colgate Eco is its lightweight make – only 9.6lbs. It contends for easy sheet change and flip-over if need arises. Furthermore, I feel it’s a bargain among its competitors due to the value-adds it has.

Moreover, it has a dual firmness make, one side firmer than the other side. To us, a firm mattress feels uncomfortable for the baby, but in actual sense babies needs a firm, even, and flat surface to sleep. On such a mattress, they maximize on their development and growth in their muscle strength. Moreover, a flat surface ensures there is enough space to enhance breathability in the crib.


  • Dual -sided adding value for money

  • It is Eco-friendly and lightweight

  • It has no smell


  • Stains can be hard to get rid off

  • Rounded corners instead of squared edges

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress


Features to Consider:

Moonlight comes in as second in my favorite picks for the best baby mattress since it adopts a similar dual-sided innovation. The extra firm and Eco-friendly side, which is also plant oil infused foam is suitable for infants. As your angel transforms into a toddler, the other soft plush side offers enough comfort. The cover is made of medical grade fabric, which is waterproof. Additionally, the durable stretch fabric has extra strewn seams to ensure it is strong and tight on the mattress. Moreover, the cover has a certificate for being free of toxins and has a negligible impact on indoor air environment due to low VOC count.  

For me, a mattress to qualify as best for babies it needs to be almost 100% waterproof. This mattress, in my opinion, excels on this measure. Furthermore, it is hypoallergenic, bed bug and dust mite free. Similarly, this mattress is CertiPur-US and GreenGuard certified.

My View:

As a matter of fact, Moonlight Slumber, in my opinion, is value for money. For me, dual-sided mattresses may be the real deal since you do not have to look for money to replace the mattress when your baby grows into a toddler. In addition, I had fear that the mattress would smell since it was foam based. To my surprise, and for babies benefit, this mattress is almost smell-free except for the new packaging odor that goes away instantly.

First of all, upon unpacking it, I couldn’t help but delight on how featherweight the mattress is in the first place. For those of us that have dealt with night, diaper explosions know the value of this kind of a mattress. You need a mattress that you can change the sheets quickly and with little effort.


  • Affordable

  • Extra strewn seams make a flat surface

  • Easy to change sheets and eco-friendly

  • It is dual sided


  • Some customers thought it to be too firm

Milliard Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed Mattress

Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress


Features to Consider:

Milliard Crib Mattress is my favorite pick for a budget mattress if you would like the value on a relatively small expenditure. It offers a blend of foam mattress that provides comfort and safety for our young ones. Interestingly, its top and sides is made of a waterproof encasement. This encasement is hypoallergenic and nonporous on the surface. Incidentally, the manufacturer designed it purposefully to prevent bacteria, dust mites, allergens and molds from permeating from underneath onto your baby.  

In addition, the bottom is made of pores for better airflow and has anti-flame materials. The mattress texture and feel is sturdy and comfortable, your baby is well supported and cradled throughout the night. Delightfully, the mattress arrives slightly smell free despite the fact that it is foam based in its construction. It is also very lightweight and manufactured in standard measurements as prescribed by the US government, it fits seamlessly in your crib.

My View:

One of the reasons I loved Milliard Crib Mattress is due to its affordability. Moreover, the manufacturer did not have to compromise on quality but instead chose to offer simplicity. I also felt this mattress’ surface offers better protection against SIDs but again being cushy enough to prevent your infant’s head from flattening. About the manufacturer, I have come to learn that they continuously test their products on a large scale with a view of optimizing production for highest customer satisfaction. This is reassuring to learn, it instills confidence that your baby is safe.


  • Unbelievably comfortable and affordable

  • It has an attractive trademark pattern on the surface

  • It is waterproof


  • Smells quite a little bit in the first 72 hours

  • Takes a while to inflate to its factory measurements

Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress

Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress


Feature to Consider:

For your baby, I would probably suggest organic mattresses as the best baby mattress. They are relatively expensive, but with a good reason. They offer premier protection and comfort to the baby’s tender and supple body.

So what makes this mattress unique?

It is innovative by adapting food-grade polymer wovenaire as its primary manufacturing material. It is free from latex, glue, gels, foam, springs, bacteria, and allergens. The cover is 100% polyester and made into 3D subtle patterns that quickly collapse on the slightest touch. I tried to unzip the cover and it was a delight. During the rush the night, you want to be able to change covers instantly if need arises. I felt that the whole mattress allows free airflow, breathability and temperature regulation. In fact, the manufacturer claims to have carried out tests and discovered babies can breathe right through the mattress without suffocating.

My View:

To sum it up, Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress in my view qualified as my upgraded pick solely due to its build material, organic and design. Interestingly, this mattress is among the few that you can wash completely after removing its cover. Moreover, organic mattresses usually last for a long time; you can use it in both stages of your baby’s growth, when they are an infant and when they grow into toddlers.

For me, it gives me much comfort to know this mattress did not have any foam, latex or springs and manufactured 10% from food grade polymers and 90% air! This I feel is mighty important as it secures the health of your baby.


  • Made of food grade organic polymers only

  • 100% washable

  • Lightweight

  • No harmful chemicals


  • It is an expensive mattress but worth every penny

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress


Features to Consider:

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress is causing ripples in the best mattress for babies category. The manufacturer has an interesting approach on built-material. Reassuringly, this award-winning mattress is made of renewable natural soybean materials from American firms. These blend with foam to create a lightweight and ultra-durable mattress. This innovation passes the GreenGuard, CertiPUR-US quality tests and has won the manufacturer a few awards for their efforts. Similarly, the cover is stain resistant and reinforced embossed waterproof binding that is lock stitched to resist any moisture infiltration.

Interestingly in the light of this, allergens like dander and dust wipe away almost instantly instead of sticking onto the surface. Sealy has a knack for durable quality, and this mattress is no exception. The mattress lasts in its original form for over five years, it literally oversees your young tender baby transform into an adorable toddler.

Astonishingly, this best baby mattress can support a baby and toddler with a weight of up to 60 pounds!  

My View:

What makes Sealy tick in the first place? For four years in a row, the company has won the Women’s Choice Award! They must be doing something very right with this product. They have let parents decide on the make of the product they desire for their babies. The innovative idea of manufacturing a mattress out of a blend of foam and soybean seems to augur well with most parents. Pound for pound, Sealy mattress offers your baby the best comfort and safety in my opinion. It is firm enough to support your baby, but also comfortable enough to match your toddler’s sleep needs.


  • Has won Women’s Choice Award for 4 years in a row

  • Has no smell

  • Easy to clean

  • Waterproof

  • Easy to change sheets


  • A little firm for toddlers

  • Makes noise when shifted

How To Choose The Best Mattress For Babies

How to Choose the Best Mattress for Babies

First of all, It might interest you to know the federal government in the USA has strict regulations that govern baby beddings, baby mattresses being one of them. In addition, babies spend up to 70% of their time in a crib. It naturally follows that you put a lot of consideration into the kind of mattress you will purchase for your baby. By law, crib mattresses for babies and toddlers must be at least 27 1/4” inches by 51 5/8” and within 6” inches thick. The mattress needs to fit seamlessly in the crib without leaving gaps. Similarly, ensure the surface is firm, even and flat. Infants are susceptible suffocation and SIDs.

Also, ensure the mattress you settle for is of good quality. The cheapest mattresses usually tend to be foam and innerspring. Organic and latex mattresses offer quality at higher prices. Highly priced mattress options tend to offer a firmer surface hence they are safer.

What Are The Benefits Of Mattress For Babies?

What are the Benefits of Mattress for babies?

Having the best mattress for your baby ensures the chances of your baby suffocating or be at risk of SIDs is minimal. Similarly, baby’s immune system is not well developed. A good mattress would protect them from allergens, bacteria, and dust mites.

  • Safety

    Babies are very delicate. They need a lot of care. Even though they sleep for long periods, they constantly wake up if their sleep is not as cozy as they like it. It is therefore imperative to make sure that the surface your baby spends most of their time is free from danger and offers protection against suffocation and SIDs. Best baby mattress has this capability to a higher degree than normal-cut mattresses.

  • Cleaning

    Baby mattresses are easy to clean. In fact, some mattresses especially of organic extracts are fully washable. This is paramount since you may occasionally experience a diaper explosion and you do not want to lack options. Most baby mattresses have a surface that you simply wipe off with treated water, and they will be clean for your baby to get back on.

  • Quality Assurance

    Most baby mattresses are either CertiPUR-US or GreenGuard certified. These marks of quality assurance indicate your baby’s crib mattress has undergone rigorous tests against harmful chemicals and radicals. As alluded to, babies spend a lot of their time on the mattress, they need to be clear of any chemicals.

Attributes That Differentiate The Best Mattress For Babies

Attributes that Differentiate the Best Mattress for Babies

You should take time and be very choosy when selecting the best mattress for your baby. Some of the things that you have to consider as you head out are:

  • Comfort

  • Firmness

  • Ease of cleaning

  • Build materials

  • Cost

  • Certifications

  • Measurements

What Is The Best Way To Use This Product?

What is the Best Way to Use This Product?

Make sure you follow the manufacturer’s directions, especially for foam-based mattresses. Furthermore, use treated water to clean the surface of the mattress whenever it is dirty. Do not lay the baby on a wet surface; ensure that the surface is clean. It is advisable to air the mattress for a few hours to a couple of days especially if it is a foam-based mattress to lose the smell.

Does The Best Baby Mattress Prevent SIDs?

Moreover, there has been a controversy if sleeping surfaces contribute to SIDs. The answer surprisingly is yes. Uneven and extra cushy mattresses place your baby at risk of suffocation and SID. You have to make sure that your infant sleeps on a firm mattress that is flat and even. Babies are quite agile, and as they grow, naturally they will attempt to turn over. If your baby manages to turn, a firm mattress offers the best protection in this case.  

Read Other Latest Tests!





In Conclusion

To sum it all up, Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness crib mattress is my favorite pick for the best mattress for babies. The dual firmness aspect is innovative enough to offer protection for your baby while the less firm side offers comfort to your toddler, it is durable and ensures top value for money. The cover is made of ultra-soft organic cotton cover, proving health benefits for your baby. Overall, its price is fair for all the benefits it offers.

This is Sandra McElroy. My mission is to help BedtimeFriends readers research, & pick mattresses & various other sleep products that suit their needs, & budget.
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *